An Illinois law promised to cover doulas. For many families, it hasn’t

 
a black woman with long hair wears a blue sports bra and blue exercise shorts; she is quite pregnant, and another black doula sits on a couch facing the pregnant woman, with her hands on the woman's belly. she's wearing a white T-shirt and blue jeans. a black man in a blue shirt sits on the counch next to the doula

Adobe Stock

// This is a machine generated transcript. Please report any transcription errors to will-help@illinois.edu.

Brian Mackey  •  00:07
From Illinois Public Media, this is The 21st Show. I'm Brian Mackey. And we begin today with a grim statistic it's estimated that black women who are pregnant are about three times as likely as other women to die from pregnancy related causes policy advocates call this the maternal mortality gap And two years ago, Governor J.B. Pritzker signed a law called the Birth Equity Initiative, aiming to close that gap. One part of that law requires private insurance companies to cover doulas, professionals who support women and their families during and after childbirth. But when many women here in the 21st state are still having trouble getting their insurance to pay for doulas, Take Eleanor Grano, who planned her latest pregnancy around the law, as explained in this excerpt from a news story by Chicago Public Radio health reporter Kristen Schorsch. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  00:59
A Blue Cross representative tells Grano the benefit is not available. So she contacts her two state reps, who intervene immediately. Then she learns her benefit would start when her health insurance plan renewed July 1st. Grano was relieved. She became pregnant with a girl. 

Eleanor Grano  •  01:15
I just remember going into my embryo transfer being like, okay, we got this. I'm not going to have to feel like I'm in crisis for the second pregnancy like I have a doula. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  01:26
Then she tries to book her doula and hits a wall. Blue Cross tells her they only have five doulas in their network for the entire Chicago area. So Grana would have to find a doula out of network, pay her around $10,000 to cover a month of overnight visits, then get Blue Cross to pay her back. 

Eleanor Grano  •  01:43
My case manager from Blue Cross will ask me, how am I doing? I was like, how am I doing? I have high blood pressure and this whole situation is giving me even more high blood pressure. 

Brian Mackey  •  01:54
The story is called This Illinois Law Was Supposed to Help Families. It's Failing Them Instead. We'll make sure to put a link to it on our website after the show, 21stshow.org. But joining me now to talk more about what's happening is Kristen Schorsch from WBEZ. Kristen, welcome back to The 21st Show. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  02:12
Thank you for having me. 

Brian Mackey  •  02:13
And listeners, you can join us throughout the first half of our program today about this topic by giving us a call at 800-222-9455. Maybe you have had the help of a doula during and after pregnancy. What was that like for you? How is it different from other ways of getting pregnancy care? And what do you think of Illinois trying to get insurers to cover that care? Maybe you've even had trouble accessing the care under this new law. 800-222-9455 is the number to join us today. 800-222-9455. All right, Kristen, we heard that excerpt from your reporting in the introduction. What happened to Eleanor after that? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  02:57
Right. Well, so as you described, I mean, as you played, I mean, Eleanor spent nearly her entire pregnancy fighting her insurance company, Blue Cross, to not have to pay up front. So Blue Cross wanted her to pay about $10,000, which was going to cover about a month of overnight visits when Eleanor got home with her baby, right, to cover doula services. After, you know, Ellen and I talked for several weeks about this story, right when I, during my reporting and I was, you know, calling Blue Cross trying to get answers for Eleanor, in the end, she ended up not having to pay that $10,000 up front. So she went into having her baby with some release and peace. I have since checked in with her. You know, she's still trying to make sure that she doesn't get balance billed or have to pay any sort of cost. But in the meantime, you know, I talked to several other families and doula agencies and Representative Robin Gable, state representative, said she's going to file a bill in January to fix this law. And we can get into why and what what she wants to fix about it. 

Brian Mackey  •  04:06
Yeah, let's put a pin in Robin Gable. We'll come back to that sort of like what's next part of your story later. But, you know, this strikes me that this is once again one of those examples where the American health insurance system works great for people who can get their problems covered in the media. Not the first time we've seen this. You know, let's take a step back. What does a doula provide for women who are pregnant that, you know, they might not get from, you know, traditional medical establishment? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  04:35
Right. So, you know, you can have a doula before, during and after your birth. So, you know, you can talk with them before about, you know, prenatal care. They really help educate you on how to advocate for yourself. When they're in the labor and delivery room with you, they can help manage pain, again, kind of help advocate for you and your wishes when, you know, anyone who's gone through labor can testify about how hard that can be and then just the stress you're under, of course. And then when you get home, they can essentially help take care of your baby overnight. For Eleanor and her husband, you know, they would have a doula come from about 10 p.m. to 6 a.m., really giving them time to kind of rest and recuperate. 

Brian Mackey  •  05:18
Wow. That is that sounds mind blowing. Somebody who's been through that without without a doula. You know, so that's that's the sort of like personal individual experience of it. What do we know about health outcomes? What difference can having a doula make in terms of like, you know, what the research tells us? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  05:36
Right. Well, having a doula talk, you know, there's there's research that backs up that it's linked to better health outcomes for both moms and babies. So fewer premature births, lower C-section rates, you know, C-sections come with a litany of health risks as well. So there's been research that shows that it can really help. And that's why you're seeing not just Illinois, but a lot of other states across the country starting to call for covering doulas, like having them be part of your insurance products. 

Brian Mackey  •  06:08
Okay. So let's say somebody with it, you know, setting aside the law for now or insurance coverage, how much can doula services cost? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  06:18
Well, doulas can be, they can be expensive. I mean, you know, for a birth, to have a doula at your birth, you know, it could be a couple of thousand dollars. For a postpartum doula, it can be a lot more. It depends on how many visits you want and how like how long you want to have a doula for. So for Eleanor, the law, the state law that she was trying to use was going to cover about a month of visits capped at $8,000. So imagine if you could have someone come to your house. If you don't have family and friends around or you choose not to use that route, having someone come to your house for eight hours overnight for up to a month, that can be pretty transformative for a lot of families. It can really help out, especially if you have another kiddo at home. So think about that cost up to $8,000. Private insurance are supposed to cover that now. 

Brian Mackey  •  07:09
And so, OK, we've mentioned now that the doula coverage was one of the things included in this birth equity initiative. Say more about about that law. What was what was the thinking behind that? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  07:20
Well, like you mentioned, there's a huge disparity in terms of maternal mortality in this state. There was also this the big idea was really trying to help save the lives of more of more pregnant women and postpartum. Postpartum can be a particularly dangerous time for a lot of women in Illinois. We've seen that the public health department has studied that. And it was also this this bigger idea of of helping of helping women with everything from even like lactation consultants to investing in birth centers to diapers. Like the state had this big, broader plan to truly help families. And so cover having private insurance companies cover doulas was part of that part of that big idea. 

Brian Mackey  •  08:06
All right. Let me remind people this is the 21st show. We're talking about an Illinois law that was supposed to expand women's access to doulas, the professionals who support them during and after childbirth. Many women are still having problems getting that care covered by insurance. And we're talking about why that is with WBEZ health reporter Kristen Schorsch. If you want to join us, 800-222-9455 is the number. That's 800-222-9455. All right, Kristen. So that's, you know, how it started, what it's supposed to do. How's it going? Why isn't this quite working the way lawmakers hoped it would? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  08:47
Yes. So that's a great question. This took me quite a bit to figure out because there were just a lot of hoops to jump through, right? Like any reporting process when you're asking a lot of difficult questions. I found two big reasons for why this is happening to families across the state. For one, the majority of people in Illinois who have private insurance have plans that the state cannot regulate. So these families insurance plans, they're not required by the state to cover doulas, though they can. And I think a lot of people don't realize that. Right. I mean, you might not know what kind of health plan that you have. So that's a big thing. And then the other thing is for people whose insurance companies are required to cover doula services. When state lawmakers wrote this law, they left out a key piece of it. So they did not create a standard for how many doulas insurers must have in their networks, or how far people have to travel to access one. And so this is a big deal because there are standards for pediatricians to surgeons, meaning that, you know, you have to make sure that within your insurance network, within your insurance plan, that you're going to have access to a doctor, right? If you don't have a standard for doulas and require insurance companies to have one, that basically means that they have been able to decide how many doulas they have in their network. So for Eleanor Grano, for example, for example, when she was trying to find an in-network doula and, you know, in-network providers are typically always cheaper than going out of your insurance network. So for Eleanor, when she had reached out to Blue Cross, making sure she could, you know, have this benefit, there were only five doulas in the entire network, in the entire Chicago area, five. Eleanor reached out to all of them. They weren't available for one reason or another. So that's why they said, OK, well, you'll have to go out of network. You'll have to pay up front, which would cost her about ten thousand dollars. And then we'll pay you back later, which is a huge financial risk. Right. To think your insurance company will pay you back that much money. That is happening to a lot of families across Illinois is that their insurance networks do not have enough doulas. They aren't required to have a certain number of doulas. And this is the part that State Representative Robin Gable told me she plans to fix next year when she files a bill, which, of course, she'll need the support of other lawmakers and the governor would have to sign that as well. 

Brian Mackey  •  11:22
Yeah. And we'll still we'll come to her in a minute. But, you know, what, aside from calling you and calling other reporters to try and get publicity for their stories, what options do the families dealing with these roadblocks have to fight back? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  11:36
Yeah. And I will just say, of course, like my intention is it's always to help people when they reach out. But it's not just to it wasn't just to help Eleanor and her family. Right. You're not an ombudsman. 100 percent. No, no, no. I mean, this is a state law. Lieutenant Governor Juliana Stratton spearheaded the birth equity initiative. It's a huge deal. It's a very important law. But I reached out to her office as well, and she refused an interview about this. This is a really big deal. It can help a lot of families. And it's not working. And if we have a state law in the books, like it should be helping families as intended. Right. So Eleanor is not the only person I talked to for the story. I talked to many families. And even after it ran, I talked to more families who said, I'm going through the exact same thing Eleanor is going through. You should look up the Instagram post that we have on look up WBEZ's Instagram feed and you can see other people weighing in on how this has happened to them. I would encourage people to file a complaint with the Illinois Department of Insurance. That is going to be one of the only ways they're going to understand the scope of this problem. because when I started reporting on this a few months ago, you know, of course, I reached out to DOI, the Department of Insurance, and asked, have you heard about this problem? How big of a deal is it? I had put in a public records request asking for complaints around getting access to doulas with their private insurance companies. I only got a few back. But now that the story has run, and people are really coming out and saying this happened to me, a lot of people don't know that they can file a complaint with the state. You know, can you imagine being a person who is pregnant or just had a baby? You're trying to access this law. How much time do you truly have to navigate this? I mean, as I pointed out in the story, Eleanor fought nearly her entire pregnancy just trying to access this law. So it's very time consuming. 

Brian Mackey  •  13:29
Yeah. Paperwork is not your number one thought when you are trying to keep a tiny human alive. A hundred percent. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  13:35
Right. And when you're getting the runaround. I mean, you know, Eleanor shared her messages back and forth with Blue Cross. I mean, it was a huge effort for her to get to the point where she was just trying so hard to access a legal benefit. 

Brian Mackey  •  13:51
You know, we've been talking about the sort of consumer side of this. And I should say we have to take a break in a couple of minutes. But before we do, there's also challenges for the doulas being a part of these networks, right? Talk about that. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  14:04
Right. So I talked to a lot of doula agencies and, you know, a lot of doulas are either, you know, kind of, you know, work on their own, for example, or they're in small organizations. They aren't typically used to being part of an insurance network. And even if I talk to one very large organization, doula agency in Chicago, which works with more than 500 doulas, and they're all independent contractors. They're not employees. And so one of the things that they are worried about, if they have to become part of an insurance network, is actually getting paid on time. So for example, this is not a new complaint, but insurance companies, if you're a doctor and you file your claim to get reimbursed from the patient that you just treated, it can take weeks to months to get paid back. And a lot of doulas have other jobs, right? Like maybe they're teachers or some other kind of employment. And so having to wait that long to get paid can be pretty anxiety inducing because they know that that is a pattern in this industry. And so that's a really kind of big worry. I also know that doulas have told me they have tried. They've reached out to insurance companies trying to become part of their networks, and they haven't even heard back. And this piece of the law, private insurers being required to cover doula services at no cost to families. This piece kicked in on January 1st. So insurance companies were supposed to be ready on January 1st with networks of doulas. So there's a lot of issues going on at play. 

Brian Mackey  •  15:42
Yeah. And this is, I mean, this is a broader story in the healthcare industry, and we can talk about this after the break. But like, you know, I've seen in the town where I live, like a lot of dentists saying, well, we're no longer going to be in network. You get reimbursed from the, you you know, public universities or state government. But that is, you know, that's a conversation we can have another day. We're going to continue with Kristen Schorsch of WBEZ about access to doulas and whether the new law intended to improve access to that through insurance, private insurance, is working as intended. It's not. If you want to join us, 800-222-9455. We'll be back. This is The 21st Show. Stay with us. it's the 21st show i'm brian Mackey we are talking about an illinois law the birth equity initiative that was supposed to expand access to doulas the professionals who support women during And after childbirth, many people are still having problems getting that care covered by insurance, even though that was one of the aims of the law, which was also sort of big picture focused on the maternal mortality gap. The fact that black women are three times more likely to die of pregnancy complications than pretty much every other demographic. We're talking about this with health reporter Kristen Schorsch of WBEZ, the public media station in Chicago. You can join us 800-222-9455. So, Kristen, it's not I always appreciate this. It's not always doom and gloom. You did write about one success story in your reporting, at least kind of. Tell me about Katie Lombardi. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  17:33
Oh, yeah. So kind of kind of success story. Right. So what happened with their family was that they already had, you know, a daughter at home. They had another baby in May. They verified with their insurance company, Blue Cross, multiple times that they that their plan was eligible for this postpartum doula. That's what they need. That's what they had wanted. A doula to help them overnight so that they can rest and recover. Also already having a big sister at home. You know, it's interesting. Katie told me when I met with her that this, you know, she said the whole thing honestly seemed too good to be true. So, you know, to the fact that they could get doula services paid for by their insurance company. 

Brian Mackey  •  18:16
I've had that thought multiple times in this conversation. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  18:19
Right. I mean, this is also a PSA. I want people to know this law exists. You can have doula services covered if your health plan is eligible. Like, please look into that. Right. It's up to eight thousand dollars, up to thirty two visits a month. Like, please check that out. So what happened with Katie and her husband, Louis, is they had a doula overnight who helped, you know, feeding, swaddling the baby, washing bottles, like helping this family rest and recover. The doula came twice. And then Katie and her husband, Louis, kind of hit a pause in this moment of panic because then Blue Cross indicated they were not going to cover it, even though Katie did her homework and made multiple calls making sure that this was covered. Then they actually get a check in the mail reimbursing them. They say, OK, we're going to go back to it. They hire a separate doula to come overnight for a few weeks, a couple times a week. They paid for that doula about forty five hundred dollars out of pocket. So they start to submit claims to Blue Cross to get paid back, which is what the law says, right, that families aren't supposed to have to pay for this. Some were fully paid and some were not. And Lewis submitted the exact same claims. And he's like, this doesn't make sense. Why are you paying me back for some and not the others? And essentially now they are in this back and forth with Blue Cross, you know, making sure that they get reimbursement. Lewis has been so organized. He's literally written cover letters explaining this is what the birth equity initiative says about doula coverage. This is how much we have paid. Here are the receipts in Blue Cross has paid them some money. and is now actually trying to claw back almost $2,000. So, you know, this is a case where, you know, I found them from the doula agency they worked with and they described Katie and Lewis as a success story because most, like every other family this agency had worked with for the most part, couldn't either get a straight answer from their insurance company of if this would be covered or just got so bogged down by the red tape that they gave up and just, they even said, They just walked away without even getting a doula, like without even having a doula because they couldn't afford it. So this is another example. It's slightly different than Eleanor's where this family did pay up front, try to get reimbursed, got some money back. Blue Cross is clawing back, wants to claw back. I should say wants to some of it. And now they're in this, you know, back and forth. And so this is just another example of a law that says doula services should be covered. here, this family, is having a really hard time with that. And they have filed a complaint with the Department of Insurance as well. 

Brian Mackey  •  21:09
Well, like Orson Welles and the third man, ask your grandparents, we have been teasing the appearance of Robin Gable in this story, the state representative who was one of the key sponsors of this legislation a couple of years ago. What are her plans? Tell me more about what she wants to do to try to address this. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  21:28
Right. So she, you know, she was a lead sponsor of this law. Like you said, this was really important to her. I talked to her a few times about this. I told her about these stories that I was hearing. And she said that she does plan to file a bill in January that would require what's called network adequacy for doulas. So basically that private insurance companies like that, that there would have to be a standard that they would have to have a certain number of doulas in their network. So that number is all going to have to be worked out, of course, if this bill does pass. But, you know, Representative Gable told me that there needs to be more pressure to make sure that the insurance companies actually recruit doulas and have them in their networks. I, you know, I reached out to the Department of Insurance, could not get an on the record interview with them because they do implement and enforce the law. So we'll see where this goes. I'm definitely going to keep an eye on it. You know, I've talked to more families. I plan to hopefully do a follow up with more stories because I do think it's important that lawmakers, you know, implementing a law is one thing, but enforcing it and actually watching it play out is another. Right. Or I'm sorry, passing a bill is one thing, implementing it, enforcing it is another. So I want to see what happens, especially with the discussion between lawmakers and insurance companies, when when this does potentially come up in Springfield after the new year. 

Brian Mackey  •  22:49
Yeah. And of course, there will be no shortage of fighting. No. Well, one expects the insurance companies are well resourced to put up a lobbying fight in Springfield if they don't like the direction it's going. Just a couple of minutes, Kristen. I know you cover a lot in the health field. What else are you watching when it comes to pregnancy and women's health right now in Illinois? 

Kristen Schorsch  •  23:12
Yeah, well, I am going to keep a really close eye on the big changes rolling out with Medicaid, which, of course, Medicaid covers a lot of births in the state of Illinois. Medicaid is public health insurance for people with low incomes or disabilities. And there are some big changes coming on January 1 out of the one big, beautiful bill that was Trump's bill. And so I'm going to definitely keep an eye on how those Medicaid changes. Basically, one of the big changes is people are going to be required to prove that they're working or volunteering or going to school a certain number of hours a month to keep their coverage. And there's a lot of fear about, you know, thousands of people potentially losing that health insurance for them and their families. So that's a big thing I'm going to be looking at. you know, staying on top of this, what's happening with doulas. And yes, I cover a lot of things. Always looking for story ideas if people want to reach out to me. 

Brian Mackey  •  24:12
The story is this Illinois law was supposed to help families. It's failing them instead. We'll make sure to have a link to it on our website, 21stshow.org. Kristen Schorsch with WBEZ. Thanks again for sharing your reporting with us today. 

Kristen Schorsch  •  24:27
You're welcome. And thanks so much. 

Two years ago, Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed Illinois' Birth Equity Initiative, a law meant to help close a stark gap: Black women who are pregnant are roughly three times as likely as other women to die from pregnancy-related causes. One piece of that law requires private insurance companies to cover doulas, the professionals who support families during and after childbirth.

But many Illinois families are still struggling to get that coverage. Eleanor Grano planned her pregnancy around the new benefit, only to learn her insurer, Blue Cross, had just five doulas in its network for the entire Chicago area. Unable to find one available, she faced paying roughly $10,000 out of pocket for a month of overnight postpartum visits, hoping to be reimbursed later.

WBEZ health reporter Kristen Schorsch has been covering the story, and joined the show to talk about why the law isn't working as intended.

Discussed

Guest

Kristen Schorsch
Health reporter, WBEZ