As most states opt into a new school tax credit, Illinois holds back
Adobe Stock
// This is a machine generated transcript. Please report any transcription errors to will-help@illinois.edu. Brian Mackey • 00:00 It's the 21st Show. I'm Brian Mackey. A few years ago, Illinois had a tax credit scholarship program. The idea was taxpayers would donate to organizations that granted scholarships to low-income students to attend private schools. For every dollar they donated, they'd get a tax rebate of 75 cents. The program started in 2017 under Republican Governor Bruce Rauner. But then Governor J.B. Pritzker came into power and Democrats let the program expire at the end of 2023. Now, however, a new federal scholarship tax credit program is starting, and this time it's for both private and public schools. Republicans in Washington enacted this last year as part of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, and it goes into effect this coming January. But there's a catch. In order for taxpayers to benefit, individual states must opt in to the program. And Illinois has not yet done so. Joining me to talk about why is Makiya Seminera, who reports on Illinois education policy for the news organization Chalkbeat Chicago. Makiya, welcome to The 21st Show. Thanks for being with us. Makiya Seminera • 01:13 Thanks so much for having me. Brian Mackey • 01:15 And listeners, you can join us for the rest of the program on this. 800-222-9455. What do you think of this idea of offering tax credits for contributing to scholarship programs? Maybe you used Illinois' program back when it was in place. What was your experience? And what do you think of Illinois not opting in, at least so far, to this federal program? 800-222-9455 is the number. 800-222-9455. All right, Makiya, say more than I did in the introduction there about how this new federal tax credit is going to work. Makiya Seminera • 01:53 Yeah. So, you know, this program, as you said, launches next year. The program came into existence through H.R. 1 or otherwise, you know, called Trump's big, beautiful bill. And this program allows individual taxpayers to donate up to $1,700 towards scholarship granting programs that basically put money towards tuition or educational resources for both public and private schools. Anyone can donate up to that amount. But the big caveat, you know, as you were just saying, is that students that are in states that don't opt in, they cannot benefit from, you know, the money that's donated. So Illinoisans will get to donate to this regardless. But whether or not that money goes to Illinois students is the big question on everyone's mind as Governor J.P. Pritzker mulls this over. Brian Mackey • 02:57 So who is supposed to benefit from these scholarships? Makiya Seminera • 03:00 Yeah, so in this law, it outlines that students from households that had a prior year income of no more than 300% of their area's median gross income are eligible for this. You know, that's still a pretty broad range of students that are eligible, but it isn't exactly like what we see in some other states that have school choice programs that don't have any sort of income cap. So it is limited to a certain group of students. And again, that is students that go to public schools or private schools. Brian Mackey • 03:42 And what would the money go toward? I was particularly interested in the idea that, you know, public school students, what would they need scholarships for? Makiya Seminera • 03:50 Yeah, so it ranges quite a lot. You know, traditionally, private schools, you know, obviously have scholarship programs for tuition. But when we talk about public schools, that money could go towards a lot of different things. It can go towards tutoring programs, special needs services, books, computers, other supplies that are kind of associated with an elementary or secondary school's enrollment needs. So just there's kind of a broad range of educational resources that public schools can put that money towards. Brian Mackey • 04:32 So I mentioned that individual states have to opt in to this program. What sort of trends are you seeing there elsewhere in America? Makiya Seminera • 04:41 Yeah, so we have, you know, a large majority of states have opted in. 31 states have opted in as of yesterday. We do have some flat-out denials in some states, which is, you know, in Oregon, Minnesota, and Virginia just recently has said, no, we are not opting in. We've also had some decisions in Arizona and Wisconsin where the governors have vetoed legislation to opt into the program. So right now we're looking at five states that will not be participating. And then we have another, you know, more than 10 states, including Illinois, that have not yet made a decision. And, you know, the clock is ticking on that one. Again, they have until the end of the year to opt into this program. Brian Mackey • 05:37 So you mentioned Oregon, Minnesota, Arizona. The commonality I'm seeing in those states' leadership is that they are led by Democratic governors. So is this sort of falling down on partisan lines? Makiya Seminera • 05:50 For the most part, but there has been some exceptions to that. In Colorado, Governor Jared Polis opted in. He was the first Democrat to say, yes, we will join this program. And we've, you know, in the past month or so, New York has also opted in to the program. And the calculus for Democratic governors are, you know, maybe a bit more complicated. You know, there's a lot of concern about inequities that could come as a result of this program. But then there's also, you know, advocates saying, why would we leave money on the table and not opt into this program and allow Illinois to have its money sent to students in other states? Brian Mackey • 06:37 So what are some of the issues that Democratic governors have with the program as it is being implemented? Makiya Seminera • 06:43 Yeah, so there are a couple different things. The main issue that we kind of hear from Democrats is this concern that there will be some sort of, you know, that they won't have discretion over the program. And that was kind of confirmed to some extent in October when the federal government put out regulations for the program. It addressed some concerns from Democrats, but it also validated some fears. These scholarship groups that grant the scholarships, they have to conduct annual audits. There are ways to kind of verify income that make it a little bit easier on scholarship-granting programs. But at the same time, states don't really have a say over which scholarship granting organizations can operate within this program. So if there's a concern that a scholarship granting program might discriminate against gay families, for example, the states don't really have too much of a say on that issue. And that's the rub that kind of comes up for Democrats. Brian Mackey • 08:01 All right. Let me remind listeners, this is the 21st show. We're talking with Makiya Seminera, who's a reporter with Chalk Beach, Chicago, covers Illinois education policy. And we are talking about this tax credit scholarship program from H.R. 1, the federal law Republicans and President Trump passed last year, also known as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. They created a federal tax credit program for giving scholarships that can benefit students in public and private schools. Illinois used to have a similar program. They no longer do. Democrats here let that expire. But this federal program, Illinoisans can only really take advantage of it if our government, led by J.B. Pritzker, decides to opt in. And he has not yet announced which way he's going on that. We're going to talk more about the nuances of this after a short break. We'd love to hear from you. 800-222-9455. This is The 21st Show. Stay with us. it's the 21st show i'm brian mackey we are talking about a new tax credit republicans created under the one big beautiful bill act to encourage donations to scholarship funds Illinois is one of the states that has not yet decided whether to opt in, and there is some opposition to the program, especially from teachers' unions. We heard from some of you in our texting group about this tax credit, and by the way, you can join that by sending the word TALK to 217-803-0730. Karen in Champaign said, Our tax money should not go to private schools when there is no oversight whatsoever. Privatization of education will never be as inclusive as public schools strive to be. Sometimes it helps to look at the most marginalized and see what the impact would be for those people. Right now, I think that trans people and neurodivergent folks are the most likely to be mistreated by private schools. Also heard from Helen in Springfield, who said, I oppose any strategy or program that takes tax dollars away from the public school system. The thought of getting a tax credit may be tempting, but any policy or plan that reduces public support for public schools is detrimental to our American society. We also got a voicemail. Caller: Laurel from Carbondale • 10:32 Hi, my name is Laurel, and I'm from Carbondale, Illinois. And I do not want Illinois to opt in for the tax credit program that would provide financial support for children attending private schools. I don't believe tax dollars should be used to support private schools. Our daughter attended a private school for several years. We chose to send her to a private school. It was our choice, and we did not expect a tax credit to help pay for that choice. I support the teachers' union, their position, and I urge the governor to stand firm and not opt in. Thank you very much. Brian Mackey • 11:09 Laurel, thank you for the message. If you want to join us today live, 800-222-9455 is the number. What do you think about this? 800-222-9455. Or maybe you just have some unanswered questions. We'd love to put them to somebody who has been covering this closely. 800-222-9455. That person is Makiya Seminera, who reports on Illinois education issues for Chalkbeat Chicago. So, Makaya, I do want to put another listener question or set of questions to you. We heard from John in Rockford who said, does this tax credit affect the amount of money provided to Illinois public schools by the state or federal governments? And does it affect the amount of tax revenue that the state of Illinois will receive from people who use the tax credit? If not, I don't see any reason not to implement it. All right, John, thanks for that message. Makaya, can you speak to either of those questions? Makiya Seminera • 12:05 Yeah, so I think that this has been kind of one of the main questions. And I think on both sides of this issue, there's kind of some debate on this. And I think the answer to it is nuanced. When we're talking about directly impacting the tax revenue to the state of Illinois, no, this program doesn't directly take away money from state tax revenue. The tax credit comes out of federal income tax, so that doesn't impact state taxes. And the Trump administration and supporters of this program are saying that it has the potential to become one of the largest sources of federal funding for schools. You know, when we consider things like the simultaneous federal cuts to education, it's kind of hard to deduce, you know, how that kind of shakes out in the end. But, you know, supporters also see it as a good way to avoid other revenue increasing methods. You know, in Chicago, there's a lot of talk about raising local property taxes and, you know, that not being a favorable way to fund public schools. But to this question, you know, I think the concerns that a lot of people have is the indirect ways that this program can impact Illinois public schools. Enrollment is directly tied to the way schools are funded through evidence-based funding, which is the way that Illinois funds its public schools. And so if the tax credit program incentivizes families to go to private schools, the concern is that there will be declining enrollment in public schools, which is already a major issue across the country. We see declining enrollment in public schools. And so if this causes that to accelerate, the concern is that public schools will see less funding because of a declining enrollment. And then, you know, we take into account that the neediest public schools really have an uphill battle to benefit from this program more than public schools in wealthy areas or private schools in general. The requirement to have a scholarship granting organization is something that a lot of private schools already have set up because they offer scholarships for tuition. But this is new territory for a lot of public schools that don't already have this and need to kind of start from scratch to form these organizations. And so there's a need to market the program more intensely if you're a public school, because it's so out of the norm for how they raise funds. And that means convincing people to redirect a portion of their taxes, you know, towards this effort. And then, you know, lastly, I'll just say that the wealth of a community really does play a role in whether public schools will see less money from this. You know, if we assume that community members will donate to education groups in their areas, the communities that have low income families will have less money to work with than wealthier areas. Brian Mackey • 15:24 All right. This has become somewhat partisan here in Illinois. I've heard a lot of Republicans urging the governor to opt in. And we have a bit of an extended clip to play here. Back in April, I talked with Aaron Del Mar, who was Darren Bailey's running mate on the Republican ticket for governor. These scholarship tax credits programs came up. Here is how he talked about it. Aaron Del Mar • 15:47 Illinois hasn't opted in. And they say it's a tack on public schools. That's a bunch of malarkey. If you like your public school and you are 300 percent or the poverty line, you get an iPad, you get tutoring, you get all these different things that are not taxpayer dollars that are coming from the federal government. And all he needs to do is opt in. If you want money for homeschooling because that's a choice that you made for your family, or if you've decided that you want to send your child to Catholic school or Christian school and you can allocate dollars for it. But, you know what I mean? Why would you not want to do that? Because he doesn't want to give Donald Trump a win and he does it at the expense of the people of Illinois. and it's completely unacceptable. And we're not the only ones that think that. There's a whole bunch of Democrats. When it passed here in Illinois, it was bipartisan. Five years later, J.B. Pritzker held a gun to all of his state representatives, state senators, not physically, obviously politically, and they let it expire. And all these kids that have been in these ecosystems of going to the same school, playing the same sports, doing the same activities have been thrust out of their own schools. How is that humanistic? Brian Mackey • 16:42 You're talking about the scholarship tax break here in Illinois? Kids have been thrust out of their schools because of that? Aaron Del Mar • 16:48 afford it anymore. You had to make a choice between are you going to put food on the table? But the tax break was for people Brian Mackey • 16:52 donating to the school, right? Correct. But the kids that Aaron Del Mar • 16:54 were getting it, they no longer get it. The parents and the families no longer get those dollars because they allowed it to expire. So now you have a federal program that does the exact same thing and J.B. Pritzker won't opt in. Brian Mackey • 17:04 What evidence do you have? Because I haven't seen these stories about kids getting kicked out of school. Aaron Del Mar • 17:09 Is that... Yeah, that's a real thing. 14,000 families. 14,000 families, predominantly on the southwest side of Chicago that are African-American, Hispanic, and Eastern European that had school choice and opportunities for additional tutoring and additional resources, no longer have them. Brian Mackey • 17:25 All right, I should say we wanted to understand the context for that 14,000 student claim. So after the interview, one of our producers did find a news release from sort of a campaign called Save My Scholarship. It was dated February 2024, and it said the General Assembly's failure to take action to save the program will cause, will cause, it was sort of in the future tense, 14,000 students from low-income families to lose their scholarships and now may have to leave their best fit schools. Makai, what is your understanding of what happened to the families and schools benefiting from the Illinois program once it went away? Makiya Seminera • 18:01 Yeah, so in my reporting, that wasn't what I heard. I had a conversation with Josh Hale, who's the CEO of Big Shoulders Fund, which is one of the six scholarship granting organizations that were a part of Invest in Kids that could benefit from that tax credit program. And that scholarship granting group supports Catholic schools in Chicago. And in that conversation with Hale, he talked about, you know, there was some financial instability that was caused for a lot of low income families. But where I think this gets a little bit more complicated is, you know, Hale did qualify that with the fact that Big Shoulders Fund was still able to fill in the gaps to help a lot of those families and prevent them from having to leave. And so there wasn't really this story in the case of this scholarship granting program, which I will say they received 25 percent of all donations in the state program's final year. So we're talking about a total of nearly $76 million in contributions across all six scholarship programs. And Big Shoulders Fund received a quarter of that. And, you know, he he was very, you know, firm on the fact that they they did a lot to fill in those gaps. And in a conversation with St. Francis de Sales High School's principal, Ronnie Fasten, she talked about, you know, there wasn't this big exodus under, you know, this sun setting program. There was, you know, maybe a little bit of instability, which is what Hale was talking about. But they really didn't see a decline in their enrollment. In many ways, she believes that there has been a lot of growth for her school. And I'll just note that, you know, that specific high school is on Chicago's southeast side, which, you know, goes to the point of, you know, Delmar talking about this disproportionately affecting students on the south side of Chicago. Brian Mackey • 20:24 So, all right, we're coming to the end of our time together. I've mentioned the state teacher unions are not in favor of this. We've talked about some of the Democratic governors who have decided not to do this, one who did. What do we understand? What do we know or not know yet about Governor Pritzker and his decision as to whether to join or not join this program? Makiya Seminera • 20:48 Yeah, I mean, it is still to be determined. As you said, I've been kind of digging into this, trying to get some sort of inkling of which way he'll sway on this. But I will say the voices that have been involved in this debate on both sides have been extremely vocal. I was just in Springfield actually yesterday covering the push to get more funding for public schools across Illinois. And something that came up specifically from a lot of retired teachers who were there with the Illinois Federation of Teachers is, you know, calling on lawmakers to be against this program. And so they're they're very vocal that this will impact public schools in a negative in a negative way. But then we also have, you know, this kind of complicated landscape where there are some advocacy groups that advocate specifically for public schools that are also coming out and saying, wait, no, we want you to opt in. And they have also been very vocal about this in recent months, specifically Stand for Children, which supports policies that benefit public education. They believe that Illinois can maximize gains if school districts kind of build up their nonprofit infrastructure to be able to benefit from this program. And so, you know, we kind of are hearing this increased chorus of different voices calling for different things when it comes to opting in. But again, you know, Governor Pritzker has until the end of the year. So we're talking about a little over a month at this point. And, you know, there's been no real indication from him on which way he's leaning on this. Brian Mackey • 22:35 Well, I guess that answers what's usually my final question is, what are you watching for next, right? Is it just going to be hitting refresh on your email on January 1st to see if the governor's office sends anything out? Makiya Seminera • 22:46 You know, some public records requests and things of that nature to try to see if we can get that before the news release. But, you know, I think just being in touch with a lot of the stakeholders and hearing if they're hearing anything on their side of, you know, which way he's going to go on this. Brian Mackey • 23:06 Makiya Seminera reports on Illinois education issues for Chalkbeat Chicago. We'll make sure to include a link to her coverage on this on our website, 21stshow.org. Makiya, great talking with you. Thanks for sharing your reporting with us today. Makiya Seminera • 23:19 Thanks so much. Brian Mackey • 23:37 that is all we have time for today coming up on monday's program we will be live for the hour with charles isbell the chancellor the top official at the university of illinois urbana champaign We'll talk about enrollment, funding, and the state of higher education in Illinois and beyond. If you have questions, email us, or better yet, leave a voicemail. Our number is 217-300-2121. You can call that day or night. No one's going to be woken up if you get a flash of inspiration at 1 in the morning after you turn off GTA 6 for the night. 217-300-2121 is our voicemail line. And we'd love to put your questions to the chancellor of the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. The 21st Show is a production of Illinois Public Media. I'm Brian Mackey. Thanks for listening. We will talk with you again on Monday.
A new federal tax credit aimed at funding school scholarships takes effect in January 2027 — but only for taxpayers in states that opt in, and Illinois hasn't yet. The program, created under last year's One Big Beautiful Bill Act, lets individual taxpayers donate up to $1,700 toward scholarship-granting organizations that can direct the money to tuition or other educational resources, for students at both private and public schools.
Makiya Seminera, who covers Illinois education policy for Chalkbeat Chicago, joined The 21st Show to explain the landscape. She says 31 states have opted in so far, five have declined, and more than a dozen — Illinois among them — haven't decided. Most of the holdouts are Democratic-led, though not all; Colorado and New York have both opted in under Democratic governors. For those still undecided, including Illinois, a central concern is that states have little say over which scholarship-granting organizations can operate, or how they screen applicants.
Governor J.B. Pritzker has until the start of next year to decide whether Illinois joins the new federal program, and so far he hasn't signaled which way he's leaning.
Discussed
- Chalkbeat Chicago: Pressure builds on Pritzker over whether to opt Illinois into federal education tax credits
- Scholarship Granting Organizations List: Federal Scholarship Tax Credit: State-by-State Opt-In
- Chalkbeat: Public schools see 'money on the table' in education tax credit designed for private school choice
- Save My Scholarship campaign: February 2024 press release on the end of Illinois' Invest in Kids program
- The 21st Show: Meet Republican candidate for lieutenant governor Aaron Del Mar
Guest
Makiya Seminera
Reporter, Chalkbeat Chicago