Illinois police with credibility issues are still testifying in court

 
a midcentury brown-brick government building with the words Gallatin County Courthouse above the main doors. Multiple window air conditioners can be seen protruding from windows on the front of the building

The Gallatin County Courthouse in 2009. Gallatin County is where the sheriff’s office employs deputy Anthony Kendrick — and where the county’s top prosecutor is now disclosing that Kendrick lied under oath years earlier in a case brought in another county. (Daniel R. Patmore/AP) Daniel R. Patmore/AP

// This is a machine generated transcript. Please report any transcription errors to will-help@illinois.edu.

[00:00:00]
Brian Mackey: From Illinois Public Media, this is the 21st show. I'm Brian Mackey. When a police officer is called on to testify in court, their words can carry a lot of weight. There's research showing that judges and juries often trust police testimony more than they trust criminal defendants unless there are reasons not to trust the police. It's a constitutional requirement for prosecutors to tell the defense when there's evidence that might undermine the credibility of government witnesses. And for that reason, we have what are called Brady lists, which track misconduct and dishonesty among police officers. But new reporting indicates that in many cases, prosecutors were not aware of the problematic history of police officers they called on to appear in court.

This reporting comes from the Invisible Institute, a journalism nonprofit focused on, in its words, enhancing the capacity of citizens to hold public institutions accountable. They've also put together a database of officers who appear on these Brady lists. The title of their first article on this is "Illinois Police with Credibility Issues Have Arrested Hundreds of People and Testified in Court at Least 1,700 Times." We'll have a link to that on our website, twentyfirstshow.org.

Joining me now to talk about this are the authors of the report. Sam Stecklow is an investigative reporter with the Invisible Institute and Max Blaisdell is a fellow there. Sam, welcome back to the 21st show, and Max, welcome for the first time.

[00:01:39]
Sam Stecklow: Thanks for having us.

[00:01:40]
Max Blaisdell: Thanks for having us.

[00:01:41]
Brian Mackey: Listeners will be talking about this for the first half of our program today. If you have questions about this reporting, you can join the conversation at 800-222-9455. That's 800-222-9455. All right, Sam, let's start with, as you do in the story, with Anthony Kendrick. What can you tell me about him?

[00:02:04]
Sam Stecklow: So Anthony Kendrick is a Gallatin County sheriff's deputy who we found had a pretty interesting situation where a citizen complaint to the state's attorney in Gallatin County, which has about 5,000 people in the southeastern part of the state, resulted in that state's attorney finding an appellate court case that showed that Kendrick had been found to have lied to the police and fire commissioners of Johnston City in Williamson County. And this prompted the state's attorney to put him on the Brady list for the first time — you know, of an officer that we could find documentation for — in Gallatin County.

But as we report in the story, Kendrick had actually worked for five different state's attorneys' offices after that initial finding by the Johnston City police commissioners that he had lied during a disciplinary hearing. And so that finding by the Board of Police Commissioners, you know, in theory should have placed him on the Brady list in Williamson County, and then from there on, under the Supreme Court precedent, that should have followed him to each of these different counties where he ended up arresting people and testifying and working as a law enforcement officer, as he still does. In Gallatin County, he is now under investigation by the state [law] Enforcement Training and Standards Board. They say for this complaint that was about excessive force against a minor during an arrest that was submitted to the board by the Gallatin County state's attorney. But we were not able to document all of the cases in which he would have testified and that he would have necessitated disclosure to defense counsel about his history of documented dishonesty and many excessive force cases that we were able to document.

[00:03:49]
Brian Mackey: Can you say again, how did the state's attorney even come to realize that this officer had this background?

[00:03:56]
Sam Stecklow: So it seems that he received a complaint from the minor's father or parents about the excessive force against this minor during an arrest, and that prompted him to look further into Kendrick's background. It also seems that he, you know, takes photos and sells them to some kind of media organization website in southern Illinois, and that was on county time basically, and that was also part of the complaint that was submitted to the Training Standards Board.

[00:04:29]
Brian Mackey: Well, Max Blaisdell, let me bring you into the conversation now. Say more about how we know about this and, I guess, the counter — how we often don't know about these sorts of things.

[00:04:41]
Max Blaisdell: Yeah, and one of the things that we found in our reporting is that very, very few public defender's offices and private defense attorneys necessarily know about the existence of these Brady lists being maintained by their county prosecutors. It's not a regular thing that county prosecutors are necessarily sharing with them the full contents of these lists. Our understanding is that individual disclosures happen on a case-by-case basis, but yeah, these lists haven't been handed over or made public until the publication of our statewide database, which has lists of Brady records from more than 40 county prosecutor's offices across the state.

[00:05:33]
Brian Mackey: Sam, tell me more about this — the Brady list as a concept. How did this come about? What's the background there?

[00:05:41]
Sam Stecklow: Sure. So in the 1960s and 1970s there were a couple of Supreme Court cases — the U.S. Supreme Court — which laid out first that defendants in criminal cases need to be informed of any evidence which could show their innocence, so any kind of mitigating evidence or other kind of alternative suspects needs to be disclosed to their defense counsel so that could be explored at trial. And then another case which expanded that to impeachment information about government witnesses, including police officers or forensic experts. And that would be any kind of case or information that would show that the government witness had had a tendency to be dishonest, depending on the type of case. Excessive force allegations or cases could also be introduced, or other kinds of misconduct that would be germane to that specific case and the officer's role in it.

And, you know, initially, from kind of academic and historical research, there was not a lot of compliance in early years. In the last few decades, there has been an uptick in prosecutors starting to more thoroughly comply and recognize their responsibilities under this precedent by the Supreme Court. There was another case in the '90s that basically said all of the information on the prosecution team, which expands to all of the police departments involved and theoretically also the previous law enforcement agencies that employed officers who might have worked in a different county — because those allegations of dishonesty could still be brought in; it doesn't matter if it was with a different police department — those are all assumed to be within the prosecutor's control. Obviously that's not actually what happens. The prosecutor is quite reliant on police departments turning all of this over.

And so, you know, we spoke to a former Illinois appellate defender who's now a law professor in Minnesota who told us that basically, given the scope of any prosecutor's office's actual obligations under this precedent, they need to be maintaining lists of officers that may — either they will say, you know, will never be called upon because of some documented dishonesty, that means the prosecutor is saying we can't rely on this officer, which is something that [Kim Fox] did in Cook County — or a separate list that is a little bit broader of officers that they would likely have to disclose any kind of prior misconduct about, which may not prevent them from testifying in court or being called as a witness. And then it's ultimately up to the judge whether or not that can be admissible in court as well. And so, given again the scope and kind of variety of responsibilities, that's when prosecutors began maintaining Brady lists.

[00:08:36]
Brian Mackey: So Max, we mentioned the officer we were talking about had allegations of — what would you say — brutality or rough conduct with a young person. What are some of the other sorts of behavior that might be cataloged on one of these Brady lists?

[00:08:55]
Max Blaisdell: Yeah, there's really a plethora of things that are categorized on these Brady lists that prosecutors are maintaining across Illinois, and it ranges from documented instances of dishonesty — say, officers being not credible in the courtroom and a judge actually calling them out for that. It can also involve things like bias, so say racial or homophobic slurs that an officer has been documented to use. There are people who have been convicted of sexual misconduct and charged with DUIs, and they've also been placed on lists. So it really, really runs the gamut of what prosecutors say they might want to disclose. And again, as Sam pointed out, this information doesn't necessarily prevent an officer from being called to testify in court. It really just means that the prosecutor has an obligation to tell the defense attorney ahead of that officer testifying, you know, this officer has this past, [and] the judge will allow you to present this at trial before the jury.

[00:10:18]
Brian Mackey: Sam, you know, this has kind of become a pattern — I think we talked on the show two years ago about a different Illinois law enforcement officer, Sean Grayson, who had been bouncing from department to department, with people at his subsequent jobs not necessarily knowing what had gone on at his previous ones, or at least not taking it into their hiring decision. What do we understand about why Anthony Kendrick was able to keep working as an officer?

[00:10:49]
Sam Stecklow: Yeah, so we heard from the current sheriff of Gallatin County that he did do a background investigation into Anthony Kendrick prior to hiring, which has been required for many years. And that background investigation requirement was strengthened under the [Sonia Massey] Act, which was passed after [Sean] Grayson murdered [Sonja Massey] in Sangamon County. But he did tell us actually that he was aware of the disciplinary issue at Johnston City, apparently never disclosed that to the state's attorney, because the state's attorney told us that he learned about it from this citizen complaint and then doing his own background research and finding an appellate court case. And since there was no criminal implication against Kendrick, he hired him anyway.

And ultimately, with the [Sonia Massey] Act passing, what that did is essentially require these hiring agencies to go and perhaps do as the sheriff did — although we asked for the background investigation, we didn't really get any documentation; he just described that he had this knowledge. But all the [Sonia Massey] Act did was require the hiring agency to go and ask for any previous misconduct allegations or disciplinary issues with the officer in their previous law enforcement positions. There's no enforcement of that. No one is going and checking to make sure that that actually happens, and it doesn't prevent the agency from actually making a hiring decision with that in mind.

And we also found that we were unable to get records from several of Kendrick's previous employers because it seemed that the departments had shut down. We were referred from one department to a sheriff's office who referred us back to the city because they didn't, when they took over policing, they didn't take over all the records of the previous agency, and so there's just this limbo of where the records are. Perhaps the department would have better luck in finding that, but perhaps not, especially given the size of some of these really, really small departments in central and southern Illinois. We found he worked for departments of cities certainly under 1,000 people. One of them, [Beljaorrem], seems to have about 200 people, and we never got a response from trying to get records there. So there are definitely gaps in the system that still exist.

[00:13:17]
Brian Mackey: All right, we need to take a break in a few minutes, but before we do — Max, it's not against the law for someone to call a Brady-listed officer to testify in court. So what are some of the concerns that exist around that?

[00:13:33]
Max Blaisdell: Yeah, the concerns are really that a prosecutor choosing to call a Brady-listed officer might not disclose the prior misconduct, and if they are to do so, that is a constitutional violation and can be grounds for a criminal conviction being overturned. So that's a very big deal. I mean, litigating those things can cost cities a lot of money, and of course it might be that this prosecutor has convicted someone who is in fact innocent, or has negotiated a plea deal that might have been more beneficial to the defendant than they otherwise got if they had known about this disreputable officer. So that's a big deal.

I'd say the other big risk — and Sam has identified this through the Kendrick example — is that as a cop switches counties, changes departments, their history of misconduct doesn't necessarily follow them to the next prosecutor, even though there's this presumption that the next prosecutor will know about it. Prosecutors don't share their lists with each other. As I said previously, they don't necessarily share their lists with defense attorneys. And so one of the things we've really documented in this investigation is that as officers switch departments, move counties, or are based in police departments that have multiple county jurisdictions, there's a serious risk that their misconduct isn't being tracked by their next prosecutor's office, or by — in these multi-jurisdictional police departments — by their other county prosecutors.

[00:15:33]
Brian Mackey: All right, we are talking with Max Blaisdell and Sam Stecklow of the Invisible Institute. They have been reporting on police officers with histories of bias and misconduct in Illinois who are supposed to be — well, how should we say it? Prosecutors call them to testify in court at their own risk, but it turns out prosecutors are often not aware that some of these officers have problems with credibility or misconduct in their background. We're going to talk more about this after the break, including some of the database itself, which they have published with officers who are on some of these lists. And we'll talk about some of the solutions that may be in the offing for this. If you want to join us, 800-222-9455.

This is the 21st show. I'm Brian Mackey. We're talking about a new investigation focused on police officers with histories of bias and misconduct. The article out of this is called "Illinois Police with Credibility Issues Have Arrested Hundreds of People and Testified in Court at Least 1,700 Times." The authors of that piece are Sam Stecklow and Max Blaisdell with the Invisible Institute, the journalism nonprofit. Again, they've put together a database of these officers, and after the show you'll be able to find a link to that on our website, twentyfirstshow.org.

You can join us for the next just about five minutes or so at 800-222-9455. If you have a question or comment about this, don't wait — 800-222-9455. So Sam, you all put together this database. What are some of the challenges that prosecutors' offices face in putting together these Brady lists?

[00:17:35]
Sam Stecklow: Sure. So as we said, they're ultimately reliant on what police officers or departments report to them. And so we've seen this happen a variety of ways. There are certainly offices that told us that they take more proactive measures. In Kendall County, I believe the state's attorney sends out a regular notice and questionnaire to police chiefs directly, notifying them of their obligation to work with him to fulfill his obligation. Similarly, under [Kim Fox], we previously reported on certainly some issues with this process that was established in a previous series that we published with the Chicago Reader, but still there was a quite robust effort from her office to both educate assistant state's attorneys and also do a lot of outreach to both the Chicago police oversight infrastructure as well as the many, many suburban police chiefs that she had to work with to prosecute cases.

Now we've seen, under her successor [Arlene O'Neill Burke], that whole process and infrastructure that was created replaced with essentially a questionnaire — not to police chiefs but to police officers who are being called to testify in cases. And certainly there's a question that was raised at an event that we had last week at the West Side Justice Center about why would an officer who's already being accused of some kind of dishonesty then be forthcoming about that accusation of dishonesty in this new context, where it's going to affect their ability to work with the state's attorney's office.

And so there's a significant variety. And in other states, that's not really the case. You know, Illinois has 102 counties that elect 102 different elected state's attorneys. Same goes for sheriffs, and then there's, I believe, over 1,000 different municipal police departments throughout the state. And so there's all of these different levels and units of government that are theoretically all working in unison, that we have no reason to believe actually are in most cases.

Other states have a — not a similar size, but there are, you know, different county prosecutors in New Hampshire that are required to work with the attorney general's office to create one master statewide list that has a quite robust process, and for the most part it's public except for pending appeals. And in other states we've seen a more centralized approach to try to help prosecutors fulfill their duty that we really haven't seen in Illinois. The last time there was any legislative attention around this was when George Ryan was working on clearing death row and some reforms around the kind of [John Burge] era of police torture in Chicago. And we really didn't see any legislative movement on the actual Brady compliance front. There was a lot of other reforms that were put into place from that time. But all we really see in Illinois is a Supreme Court rule that very, very loosely affirmed what Brady and the U.S. Supreme Court had said under Brady, and didn't really go further than that — which, as we're saying, states certainly can.

[00:21:13]
Brian Mackey: So Sam, just about a minute left and I'm going to have to hold you to it. This article is the first in a series. What's next? I mentioned the database as well — you can talk about what you hope people get out of this, or where your reporting is going from here.

[00:21:26]
Sam Stecklow: Absolutely. So we have another story coming out shortly with the Chicago Reader that'll be republished statewide with Capitol News, that focuses on really the scope of missing officers from prosecutors — either because they came from a different county, or because there was a sustained case of misconduct at their police department that was just simply never reported to the prosecutor. Then we have another story looking at solutions in other states, as I just described. We're also planning on further events, one virtual and then one in Springfield during the General Assembly, that will be focusing on putting this in front of policymakers. And we also encourage both residents and also anyone involved in the criminal legal system to look at the database that we published to see if there's anything relevant there, and certainly other reporters to reach out if there are underlying records they want to report on and utilize. And in court, these are all public records that we want to make further accessible throughout the state.

[00:22:26]
Brian Mackey: All right, and we will have links to the database and the journalism at our website, twentyfirstshow.org. Sam Stecklow, Max Blaisdell, thanks for being with us and sharing your reporting with us today on the [21st] show.

[00:22:38]
Sam Stecklow: Thank you for having us.

When a police officer testifies in court, jurors tend to take their word over a defendant's — unless there's a reason not to. That's supposed to be where Brady lists come in: a constitutional requirement that prosecutors disclose when a police witness has a history that could undermine their credibility.

A new investigation from the Invisible Institute, a Chicago journalism nonprofit, finds many Illinois prosecutors didn't know. Reporters Sam Stecklow and Max Blaisdell identified officers with years of misconduct complaints — including one fired from one department who kept working at others — who've testified in court hundreds of times combined. More than 50 Illinois prosecuting offices, they found, report no officers on their Brady lists at all.

Discussed

Guests

Sam Stecklow
Journalist, Invisible Institute

Max Blaisdell
Fellow, Invisible Institute