Did Anyone Vote For Vivaldi?
How many can you name? No, don’t worry. I won’t ask you, unless you’ve been to the famous concert hall in Amsterdam, which is simply known as the “concert building.” That’s the meaning of the Dutch word “concertgebouw.” Even if you have been there, you may not have paid that much attention to the décor.
On the faces of the balconies, there are names of composers. I noticed a photo in the CD booklet of a recording of Antonín Dvořák’s Symphony No. 9 with Riccardo Chailly conducting the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra. Chailly, who was Music Director of the orchestra at the time, was standing in the front row of a balcony above Dvořák’s name. Another photo revealed that there are many names, though too small to be legible.
I did a little searching online and learned that there are 17 names of composers. Some are well-known. You already know one of them. Here are several more you may recognize: Tchaikovsky, Franck, Bruckner, Mahler, Debussy, Ravel, Stravinsky, Bartok, and Richard Strauss. That’s 10 out of 17. If you’ve at least heard those names, you’re batting over .500!
The others names are not as familiar: Julius Röntgen, Max Reger, Willem Pijper, Johan Wagenaar, Bernard Zweers, Alphons Diepenbrock, and Cornelis Dopper. I learned all that at the Mahler Foundation’s website about the Concertgebouw. I also learned that in 2023, Iván Fischer led a concert featuring short works by all 17 of the composers whose names appear on the balconies.
I know what you’re going to ask: “What criteria were used in selecting the names?” They’re the names of composers who performed there or whose works were premiered there. Another 29 composers, including Bach, Mozart, Haydn, Beethoven, and a host of others with classical music household names, are on the surrounding walls
All of this brought to mind a “concertgebouw” closer to home and on the campus of the University of Illinois. Thousands of people walk by Smith Memorial Hall every week, including members of the campus community and visitors. Have you been to Smith for a concert or recital? Have you noticed the names of composers on the face of the building? Do you know how many there are? Can you name them?
At this point, it would have been a perfect lead-in for a contest, with a prize given to an entry selected from among those submitting the correct answers. But I have something more interesting than that. And it’s the result of a simple question I asked recently: How did they choose the names which appear on the top edges of the building above the main entrance?
After a little searching online, I decided to get the pros involved. I’m grateful to John Laskowski of the University of Illinois Library, who consulted the folks at the University of Illinois Archives. They sent me a file which displayed a brochure which the University mailed to musicians across the country in March, 1917. It described the building under construction and asked for suggestions in selecting the names of “eminent musicians” to be inscribed on the exterior. The brochure also suggested that names could be added inside Recital Hall, which is the auditorium of Smith Music Hall. They were asked to list their choices in rank order
That was a surprise enough. But there were a couple of stories from the Daily Illini which shared some of the results of the “mail-in ballots” An article on April 13,1917 reported that there were 600 replies to the 6,000 brochures at that point. Most of the suggested composers included in the article were classical music household names. Antonín Dvořák, who was among those, had died only 13 years before. And another, Camille Saint-Saëns, was still alive.
World War I hadn’t ended. And according to the Daily Illini: “A few said that no German should be thus honored, while others asserted that no anti-German sentiment should interfere.”
Nothing suggests that it was simply the four top vote-getters who were selected, though the article mentioned that “practically ninety-nine percent of the replies center upon Bach and Beethoven,” both of whom were selected. Giovanni Pierluigi da Palestrina, the Renaissance master of sacred vocal music, and Franz Joseph Haydn were chosen as well. Their works and certainly those of every composer suggested by the musicians back in 1917 have been performed in Smith Memorial Hall, which has nurtured generations of singers, players, conductors, and composers.
I have to mention Captain Thomas J. Smith, who funded the construction of the building, which was named in memory of his wife. Originally, it was: The Tina Weedon Smith Memorial Building. And since the music of all those composers has been heard on Illinois Classical, a special thanks to all the Friends of WILL whose support helps to bring that music to our community!